A review report should be delivered in a timely manner. The authors might have submitted the paper to the journal weeks ago. Accept the review invitation only when you know you can deliver it in the given time.
A reviewer is not asked to write a damning review of the paper listing all the negative aspects that could be found. The journal wants to see you provide helpful advice to the authors about what they can do to improve the paper. If the journal would have considered the paper of so low quality that it needs to get rejected right away, they would have declined it upfront and not bothered sending it on.
A good review report points out a potential outcome for the paper. In your opinion, will this paper make it to publication? What are the essential changes or improvements that the authors need to implement to get there?
Coming up with a long list of comments on each and every detail in a paper is certainly an expression of careful reading, but the authors and the journals need to know in which direction you see this paper going. Tell them explicitly. A good review report does not only point out weaknesses, but also highlights the good aspects of a manuscript.
Reviewers too easily fall into the habit of only picking at problems and mistakes in papers. A good review report is reasonable in what it asks the authors to change. Of course, a reviewer might identify many problems and questions when reading a paper, but does this mean that the authors need to address all of them to get accepted?
Be realistic in what the authors can achieve in a revision. If your suggestion would mean they have to spend another year doing research before they can address your concern, it is not a helpful suggestion.
Of course, it might be needed to give the paper enough credibility to get published, but if it cannot be done in a reasonable time-frame, consider changing the direction you suggest the journal editor go with this paper. If your review report stretches over half of the word count of the paper itself, it is probably getting too detailed. The way reviewers express their comments has a huge influence on how they are perceived by the authors.
A good review report uses friendly and inclusive language. Hence the factors of 89 are 1 and We can use different methods to find factors of 89 such as prime factorization and the division method. In prime factorization, we express 89 as a product of its prime factors and in the division method, we see what numbers divide 89 exactly without leaving a remainder. When we use the division method to find factors of The division shows that the number 89 is exactly divisible by 1 and Example 2: Help Tim find the positive pair factors of 89 from the list of all its factors.
Factors of 89 are the numbers that divide 89 exactly without leaving any remainder. Factors of 89 are 1 and Factor pairs are the pair of two such numbers that, when multiplied, give The factors of 89 are 1, 89 and the factors of 45 are 1, 3, 5, 9, 15, This implies that 89 and 45 are co-prime.
J's study guide 1 card. What is the name of Steve on minecraft's name. Steel Tip Darts Out Chart 96 cards. Q: Use the digit 8 four times to make 89? Write your answer Related questions. What is the digit 8 four times to make 89? Use the digit 9 four times to make ? How can you use the digit 8 four times to make 89? How can you use digit 8 four times to equal 89?
Use the digit 4 four times and equal 3? Which two digit do 45 and 54 use? Use the digit 4 four times to equal 4? Use the digit 4 four times to equal 2? Use the digit 4 four times to equal 6? What is the largest 6 digit number that you can make using the digits ? What four digit number when divided by seven is the answer when the second digit from the left is dropped? How many times you use the digit 1 between 1 and ? How can you use 9 four times to make ?
Start with a three-digit number in which the digits are all different Use the digits to make all possible two-digit numbers and obtain their sum Investigate?
If a cell has a two-digit year of 32 Excel automatically changes it to a four digit year of? Whole no between 1 and use the digit 6 at least once? What 3 digit number multiplied by a 2 digit number equals a four digit number and you must use all numbers 1 through 9? How many 4-digit numbers can you make using ?
To ensure that excel interprets year values the way you intend use?
0コメント